HowToDecide Home
Related Decisions
HowToDecideTM
Review Factors. Consider Alternatives. Decide!TM

Which is the best die cut machine?

Updated 2012-11-19 at 10:53 EST
Review

Factors

Cut Control
Cost
Max Cutting Thickness
Operating System
Embosses?
Draws?
SD Card?
Requires Cutting Mat?
Cordless?
Weight
Consider

Alternatives

Narrowing 11 starting alternatives down to 11 viable alternatives:
Alternatives include affiliate links where available. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Decide

on the Best Die Cut Machine
Using 0 of 10 factors.Clear all:

Cut Control

A key distinction between die cut machines is the way in which cuts are controlled.
Value Description Pros Cons Alternatives
Cut Control
unset — click to want Computer
Software on your PC or Mac controls the cut.
  • Most flexible: opens up unlimited creativity.
  • Can download pictures to cut out.
  • Can download fonts to cut out.
  • Higher learning curve.
  • Must have computer, and computer must be compatible with die cutter machine.
  • Must be computer savvy.
  • Must have computer near die cut machine.
Silhouette Cameo, Pazzles Creative Cutter, Xyron Wishblade, eCraft Electronic, and Silhouette SD Digital
unset — click to want Cartridge
Software in add-on cartridges controls the cut.
  • Requires no computer.
  • Requires no computer savvy.
  • Provides quick-start out of the box.
  • More portable because requires no computer connection.
  • More flexible than dedicated dies.
  • Less flexible than computer control.
  • Limited by content on cartridge.
  • Expense of extra cartridge purchases.
Sizzix eclips, Cricut Imagine, Cricut Expression, Cricut Create, and Making Memories Slice
unset — click to want Die
Dedicated dies that neither require nor allow control (beyond physically swapping the dies) make the cut.
  • Requires no computer.
  • Requires no computer savvy.
  • Provides quick-start out of the box.
  • More portable because requires no computer connection.
  • Least flexible.
  • Even size change requires new die.
  • Expense of extra die purchases.
Xyron Creatopia

Cost

Value Alternatives
Cost
unset — click to want $300 and higher
Sizzix eclips and Pazzles Creative Cutter
unset — click to want $150 to $299
Silhouette Cameo, Xyron Wishblade, eCraft Electronic, Cricut Imagine, Cricut Expression, and Silhouette SD Digital
unset — click to want $149 and lower
Cricut Create, Xyron Creatopia, and Making Memories Slice

Max Cutting Thickness

Bells and whistles are nice, but in the end it's cutting that a die cut machine has to do. Be sure that the machine you buy is capable of cutting through the materials you'll want to use.
Value Alternatives
Max Cutting Thickness
unset — click to want 2 mm
Pazzles Creative Cutter
unset — click to want 1 mm
eCraft Electronic
unset — click to want 0.8 mm
Silhouette Cameo
unset — click to want 0.58 mm
Cricut Imagine, Cricut Expression, and Cricut Create
unset — click to want 0.5 mm
Making Memories Slice
unset — click to want 0.3 mm
Silhouette SD Digital
unset — click to want depends on die
Xyron Creatopia

Operating System

The machines that require a computer to operate also have certain operating system or software requirements.
Value Alternatives
Operating System
unset — click to want Mac OS X
Silhouette Cameo, Xyron Wishblade, and Silhouette SD Digital
unset — click to want Windows 7
Silhouette Cameo, Pazzles Creative Cutter, Xyron Wishblade, eCraft Electronic, and Silhouette SD Digital
unset — click to want Windows Vista
Silhouette Cameo, Pazzles Creative Cutter, Xyron Wishblade, eCraft Electronic, and Silhouette SD Digital
unset — click to want Windows XP
Silhouette Cameo, Pazzles Creative Cutter, Xyron Wishblade, eCraft Electronic, and Silhouette SD Digital
unset — click to want Windows 2000
Pazzles Creative Cutter and Xyron Wishblade
unset — click to want not applicable
Sizzix eclips, Cricut Imagine, Cricut Expression, Cricut Create, Xyron Creatopia, and Making Memories Slice

Embosses?

Embossing requires pressure from a dull tip onto the paper surface to create raised areas as well as indentations to portray the final product. Some machines come fully equipped to emboss while others require an additional kit to be purchased
Value Alternatives
Embosses?
unset — click to want Yes
Pazzles Creative Cutter, Xyron Wishblade, Xyron Creatopia, and Making Memories Slice
unset — click to want Yes, with Additional Kit
Cricut Imagine, Cricut Expression, and Cricut Create
unset — click to want No
Silhouette Cameo, Sizzix eclips, eCraft Electronic, and Silhouette SD Digital

Draws?

Many of the die cut machines also have the ability to draw. Some require special pens or markers and others can simply use a ball point pen. Many times the drawing instrument is placed where the blade is normally located.
Value Notes Alternatives
Draws?
unset — click to want Yes
Sizzix eclips, Pazzles Creative Cutter, Xyron Wishblade, eCraft Electronic, Cricut Imagine, Cricut Expression, Cricut Create, and Making Memories Slice
unset — click to want Yes, Pen
  • Can only draw with a ball point pen.
Silhouette Cameo and Silhouette SD Digital

SD Card?

Using an SD card in an electronic die cut machine enables the user to save and download various projects to be used at a later time. It is an option only found on die cut machines that work with your computer. Think of it as an alternative way to transfer files between your die cut machine and your computer without using a cable.
Value Alternatives
SD Card?
unset — click to want Yes
Silhouette Cameo, Xyron Wishblade, eCraft Electronic, and Silhouette SD Digital
unset — click to want No
Sizzix eclips, Pazzles Creative Cutter, Cricut Imagine, Cricut Expression, Cricut Create, Xyron Creatopia, and Making Memories Slice

Requires Cutting Mat?

A cutting mat goes against the material being cut, providing a backing against which the die presses and cuts.
Value Alternatives
Requires Cutting Mat?
unset — click to want Yes, Glass
Making Memories Slice
unset — click to want Yes
Sizzix eclips, Pazzles Creative Cutter, Xyron Wishblade, Cricut Imagine, Cricut Expression, Silhouette SD Digital, Cricut Create, and Xyron Creatopia
unset — click to want No
Silhouette Cameo and eCraft Electronic

Cordless?

Cordless die cut machines can be manual (Xyron Creatopia) or battery-powered (Making Memories Slice) and are more portable but less powerful than corded machines.
Value Pros Alternatives
Cordless?
unset — click to want Yes
  • More portable.
Xyron Creatopia and Making Memories Slice
unset — click to want No
Silhouette Cameo, Sizzix eclips, Pazzles Creative Cutter, Xyron Wishblade, eCraft Electronic, Cricut Imagine, Cricut Expression, Silhouette SD Digital, and Cricut Create

Weight

Die cut machine weights vary by more than 7x. Consider weight vs various other capabilities, especially if portability is important to you. If you have dedicated table space for your die cut machine, weight won't matter much. However, if you frequently have to set up and put away the unit, or if you like to take it with you to join friends for scrapbooking, die cut machine weight is worth considering.
Value Alternatives
Weight
unset — click to want 30 lbs
Cricut Imagine
unset — click to want 17 lbs
Cricut Create
unset — click to want 16.5 lbs
Sizzix eclips
unset — click to want 16 lbs
Pazzles Creative Cutter
unset — click to want 13 lbs
Cricut Expression
unset — click to want 12.5 lbs
Xyron Creatopia
unset — click to want 11.5 lbs
eCraft Electronic
unset — click to want 6.5 lbs
Silhouette Cameo
unset — click to want 6 lbs
Xyron Wishblade
unset — click to want 4.5 lbs
Silhouette SD Digital
unset — click to want 4 lbs
Making Memories Slice